See, within the liberal portions of American society, Judaism is probably the only religion deemed acceptable by the secular set. As much as fallen Catholics might pour scorn on the faith of their births, most would never dream of doing so to Judaism. This is probably because Judaism, as it is practised by the majority of its believers in the States (aka: Conservative and Reform Jews), is a relatively liberal, social justice minded, forward thinking faith in most ways. There just isn't that much there for anti-religious types to get all worked up about, foreskin slicing aside. Jews in American society have often been some of the country's brightest cultural lights in academia, the arts, business, science, and so on. And despite some notable outliers, Alan Greenspan and the anti-religious Ayn Rand being two examples, they have often been the sorts of people liberal minded Goys really really like. Plus, Jews can still be Jews without really practising Judaism, which makes them the post-modern secularist's dream come true.
Americans love an underdog. Scanning the last two-thousand years of Western history, one would be hard pressed to find a group more consistently and repetitively oppressed than the Jews. Across Europe they were subject to repeated expulsions, massacres, forced conversions, and a whole host of really atrocious shenanigans. Consider that Magna Carta, that first bloom of liberalism in England in 1215 CE, was followed only 75 years later by the expulsion of all Jews from English soil for 350 years. What a downer! No need to really explain the next thousand or so years of anti-Jewish treachery. Long story short, the Jews are history's underdog par excellence. This means all Americans who have shed the anti-semitism of their forebears can really appreciate the Jews, and love to try and identify with them. Hey, the SS would've gone after me, too, donchaknow? So, in wedding the underdog motif with the identity-victimization motif, there is just so much for non-Jewish liberals to really latch onto and try to claim as their own, that it proves very difficult for us/them not to try and do so!
Which is silly, for a lot of reasons. Much as we might admire Judaism and our Jewish pals, non-Jews can't really often become Jews. We've all seen that twit Charlotte trying to give up
Happy Passover, Jews, and to all you Christians out there: have an appropriately miserable Holy Week!

I LOVE this post!!! Well done you!
ReplyDeleteLove it!
ReplyDelete